There was a suicide bombing incident in Pakistan on May 27. Does this mean that the scholars who have issued this fatwa do not have any respect among their followers or they are not worth respecting or it is just a mob rule in Muslim world -- total mayhem and no discipline. Sorry state of affairs.
Well, the state of affairs in the Muslim world is far from ideal. But whether religious leaders have respect or are worth respecting is the same problem other communities have; do people who kill, or try to kill doctors and judges prove that the world of Christianity today is "total mayhem and no discipline"?
Your comparison is irrelevant here. In recent times, I doubt that in any other religion people are blowing themselves and killing innocent human beings considering this act as their religious duty, with overt/ covert sanction by religious authorities.
On the contrary this seems to be a norm in the majority Muslims as there has been another suicide attack on minority sect in Pakistan. How the problem can be solved when intellectuals fail to acknowledge that?
Seems like you've not heard about the Tamil Tigers, who were the first to carry out suicide bombings in the post-WWII era.
And how is this the "norm" in the "majority Muslims"? Could you give some numbers?
I wish you would not be anonymous--it would be better to talk to you if there was an e-mail address or blog address or something we could talk through. Even if it wasn't your real name.
WadiWallah
Life, technology and getting by in Silicon Valley Rickshaw!
The Id of South Asia Urdu ke Naam
A collaborative blog dedicated to the language of Urdu Cemendtaur
A Silicon Valley writer trapped in an engineer's body Khaab Khayaal Saraab
Raw train of thought waiting to get in to this blog Azad South Asia
Parent of This Blog DesiCritics.org
iFaqeer contributes to this member of the Blogcritics.org family of sites, covering media, culture, politics, sports and more with a global South Asian focus.
5 Comments:
There was a suicide bombing incident in Pakistan on May 27. Does this mean that the scholars who have issued this fatwa do not have any respect among their followers or they are not worth respecting or it is just a mob rule in Muslim world -- total mayhem and no discipline. Sorry state of affairs.
Well, the state of affairs in the Muslim world is far from ideal. But whether religious leaders have respect or are worth respecting is the same problem other communities have; do people who kill, or try to kill doctors and judges prove that the world of Christianity today is "total mayhem and no discipline"?
Also, see a previous post on my take on violence and fanaticism and one interesting echo from the past in this respect.
Your comparison is irrelevant here. In recent times, I doubt that in any other religion people are blowing themselves and killing innocent human beings considering this act as their religious duty, with overt/ covert sanction by religious authorities.
On the contrary this seems to be a norm in the majority Muslims as there has been another suicide attack on minority sect in Pakistan. How the problem can be solved when intellectuals fail to acknowledge that?
Seems like you've not heard about the Tamil Tigers, who were the first to carry out suicide bombings in the post-WWII era.
And how is this the "norm" in the "majority Muslims"? Could you give some numbers?
I wish you would not be anonymous--it would be better to talk to you if there was an e-mail address or blog address or something we could talk through. Even if it wasn't your real name.
Tamil terrorism was not sanctioned or conducted by religious zealots. It was a secular movement.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home